Asphalt shingles are the most popular roofing material in Columbus due to their durability, affordability, and wide range of color and style options. At Benchmark Roofing, we specialize in complete asphalt shingle replacements and installations using top brands like GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning. With 26 years in business since 1999, our family-owned and operated company delivers high-quality asphalt roofing solutions that protect your home and provide long-lasting value. As a GAF Master Elite® certified contractor, we offer industry-leading installation standards and can work directly with insurance companies to make your asphalt roofing project as seamless as possible.
Why Choose Benchmark Roofing for Your Asphalt Shingle Roof in Columbus, OH
INDUSTRY-LEADING CERTIFICATIONS
- GAF Master Elite® Certification: Our highest certification with GAF, the number one selling shingle manufacturer in the Americas.
- CertainTeed Shingle Master™ Certification: Professional certification for premium CertainTeed installations.
- Master Craftsman™ Shingle Quality Specialist™: Specialized certification for identifying shingle conditions and quality assessment.
- Owens Corning Certified Contractor: Standard certification for professional Owens Corning installations.
- HAAG Certified Inspectors: Professional certification to identify storm damage accurately.
Our Quality-Controlled Installation Process
DEDICATED ON-SITE PRODUCTION MANAGER
We have a full-time production manager on-site all day to supervise your project, ensure quality workmanship, address any issues immediately, and communicate with you throughout the installation.
COMPREHENSIVE PROPERTY PROTECTION
We use the Catch All Protection System—specialized chute nets and barriers that protect your landscaping, windows, siding, and doors while keeping debris contained and cleanup minimal.
DOWNSPOUT & GUTTER PROTECTION
We place foam protection in your downspouts to prevent clogs during tear-off and clean all gutters before completing the project to ensure proper drainage.
FINAL CLEANUP & MAGNETIC SWEEP
After installation, we perform a thorough cleanup of your property, including a magnetic sweep of your yard, driveway, and walkways to ensure no nails or debris are left behind.
INSURANCE CLAIM SUPPORT (WHEN APPLICABLE)
Our team works directly with insurance adjusters and provides detailed inspection documentation to make the claims process smooth and accurate.
TRUSTED, FAMILY-OWNED COMPANY SINCE 1999
Our team works directly with insurance adjusters and provides detailed inspection documentation to make the claims process smooth and accurate.
ONGOING SERVICE & LONG-TERM ROOFING SUPPORT
After your roof is installed, we remain your roofing partner. Our team is available to answer questions, assist with warranty needs, and provide guidance on maintenance as your roof ages. Every roof we install is backed by a minimum 15-year workmanship warranty, so you can count on us long after the job is complete.
GAF Asphalt Shingles We Offer
We recommend GAF shingles because they offer industry-leading durability, superior warranties, and are backed by our Master Elite certification, ensuring your roof is installed to the highest professional standards.
GAF TIMBERLINE HDZ® SHINGLES
Our most popular choice, representing 85–90% of our installations. These shingles feature the largest nailing zone in the industry at 1.5 inches, high-definition color, and Dura Grip™ adhesive for superior durability. They offer 25-year algae resistance, lifetime shingle coverage, and a 15-year infinite wind warranty.
- Color Options: Available in 16 versatile colors to match any home exterior.
- Wind Resistance: Rated to withstand winds up to 130 mph, with some sources noting a GAF “no-max-speed” wind warranty when installed with six nails per shingle and GAF’s complete roofing system.
- Impact Resistance: UL 2218 Class 3, able to resist 1.75-inch hail.
- Overall Value: Combines quality, durability, and aesthetic appeal, making it the ideal choice for most Columbus homeowners.
GAF TIMBERLINE ULTRA HDZ® SHINGLES
The premium upgrade for customers who want their roof to stand out. These shingles feature dual shadow lines and thicker construction for enhanced curb appeal and a highly dimensional appearance, while retaining all the benefits of the HDZ line.
- Color Options: Available in 6 distinctive colors for a sophisticated look.
- Workmanship Coverage: As GAF Master Elite® contractors, we can offer 30 years of workmanship coverage when installed with a qualifying GAF roofing system and registered under the Golden Pledge® Limited Warranty.
- Dual Shadow Line: Patented design adds exceptional depth for standout curb appeal.
- StainGuard Plus PRO™: 30-year limited warranty against blue-green algae, with 10% more time-release algae-fighting technology than standard shingles.
- UltraMat™ Technology: High-performance fiberglass mat strengthens the shingle core and achieves UL 2218 Class 4 impact resistance.
- WindProven™ Limited Wind Warranty: When installed with four qualifying GAF accessories, shingles with LayerLock® technology qualify for a no maximum wind speed limitation warranty.
GAF DESIGNER SHINGLES
Premium architectural shingles designed for homeowners seeking distinctive aesthetics that mimic natural materials like slate or wood. Popular options include Slateline®, Grand Sequoia®, and Woodland® collections.
- Curb Appeal: Unique textures, colors, and shadow lines for high-end looks.
- Warranty: Can be installed with the Golden Pledge® Limited Warranty for workmanship and shingle coverage.
- Durability: Made with the same advanced GAF technologies, including UltraMat™ fiberglass mat and LayerLock®, for wind and impact protection.
- Customization: Ideal for whole exterior remodels or those wanting a signature roof that complements upscale neighborhoods.
CERTAINTEED ASPHALT SHINGLES
As a Certified CertainTeed Shingle Master Contractor, we also offer the full line of CertainTeed asphalt shingles, including:
- Landmark® – Classic, durable architectural shingles.
- Landmark Pro® – Enhanced performance with thicker
construction and improved wind resistance. - Landmark Premium® – Premium aesthetics for upscale
homes with extra dimensionality. - NorthGate® – Designer shingles that mimic natural slate and wood textures.
- We can help you choose the right CertainTeed shingle for your home based on style, durability, and warranty options, providing the same professional installation quality as our GAF shingles.
Asphalt Roof Warranties We Offer
GAF SYSTEMS PLUS® WARRANTY
The Systems Plus® Warranty protects your entire GAF roofing system, including shingles, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, and other qualifying accessories, when installed as part of a complete GAF system. It provides up to 50 years of non-prorated coverage for manufacturing defects, ensuring your roof materials perform as designed. Additionally, Benchmark Roofing includes our 15-year workmanship warranty, giving you peace of mind that your roof is installed correctly and professionally.
GAF GOLDEN PLEDGE® LIMITED WARRANTY
Our premium roofing warranty offers the ultimate protection for your home. The Golden Pledge® Limited Warranty covers your entire GAF roofing system, including shingles, underlayment, starter strips, ridge cap shingles, flashing, ventilation products, and leak barriers.
Workmanship Coverage Backed by GAF: When installed by a GAF Master Elite® contractor, the Golden Pledge® warranty includes 25 years of workmanship coverage for installations with HDZ® shingles. For UHDZ® shingles, this workmanship coverage extends to 30 years, ensuring that any installation errors that cause a roof failure are covered.
Material Coverage: For qualifying Lifetime shingles, your roof also receives up to 50 years of non-prorated coverage for manufacturing defects. This means GAF covers the cost of replacement materials at 100% if a defect occurs during the non-prorated period.
Additional Coverage & Benefits
Wind protection: Coverage includes high-wind resistance, with some installations qualifying for no maximum wind speed with LayerLock® technology.
Algae resistance: Extended protection against blue-green algae discoloration with StainGuard Plus™ or StainGuard Plus PRO™ shingles.
Tear-off and disposal costs: Covered if defective materials fail during the warranty period.
Transferable: The warranty can be transferred once to a new homeowner within the first 20 years, adding value if you sell your home.
GAF-backed peace of mind: Because this warranty is backed by GAF, it remains valid even if your contractor is no longer in business.
The Golden Pledge® Limited Warranty ensures your roof is protected from materials and workmanship issues, giving you decades of confidence in your investment.
5-Step Process for Asphalt Shingle Roofing
FREE INSPECTION & ESTIMATE
We start with a free, no-obligation inspection of your roof. Our team documents the condition, takes measurements, and discusses your goals so we can provide an accurate quote for a cash project. If your project involves an insurance claim, we follow a specialized claims process—see our Insurance Claim Process here.
SHINGLE SELECTION & CONTRACT REVIEW
Once the inspection is complete, we help you choose the right shingles, colors, and any upgrades. We review the contract together so you understand the scope, timeline, and pricing before moving forward.
SCHEDULING & PRE-INSTALLATION WALKTHROUGH
After signing the contract, we schedule your project at a convenient time. Prior to installation, our production manager performs a pre-walkthrough to identify any potential concerns and plan the project for a smooth, efficient installation.
INSTALLATION DAY & PROPERTY PROTECTION
Our crew arrives early (7–7:30 AM) and sets up the Catch All Protection System to protect your landscaping, windows, doors, and gutters. Old roofing materials are carefully removed down to the decking, inspect decking and replace rotted wood if needed, downspouts are protected with foam balls, and our GAF Master Elite®-certified team installs your new asphalt shingle roofing system while our production manager supervises on-site all day.
CLEANUP & FINAL INSPECTION
At the end of each day, we perform a thorough cleanup, including gutter cleaning and a magnetic sweep of the yard, driveway, and walkways to ensure no nails or debris remain. Our production manager completes a final inspection, addressing any finishing touches. Most roofs are completed in one day, with a few finishing touches completed on a second day if needed.
Total Asphalt Roofing Support
INSURANCE CLAIM ASSISTANCE
We work as a preferred contractor with many insurance companies and help navigate the claims process from initial inspection through final approval.
INSURANCE CLAIM ASSISTANCE
We work as a preferred contractor with many insurance companies and help navigate the claims process from initial inspection through final approval.
INSURANCE CLAIM ASSISTANCE
We work as a preferred contractor with many insurance companies and help navigate the claims process from initial inspection through final approval.
Frequently Asked Questions About Asphalt Roofing in Columbus
We typically complete a roof installation in one day. Sometimes there are finishing touches to do on the second day, but the majority of the work, if not all of it, will be done in one day.
It’s a real lifetime warranty, but you have full coverage for 50 years non-prorated with our upgraded Systems Plus warranty. After 50 years, coverage becomes prorated.
GAF Timberline Shingles are the number one selling shingle in the Americas. Their warranties are top-tier, and they’re manufactured right here in America. While CertainTeed and Owens Corning are also quality brands, we believe GAF offers the best combination of quality and warranty protection for asphalt roof shingles in Columbus.
Absolutely. You can use the insurance money and then come out of pocket for upgrades like designer shingles. Many customers choose to upgrade to options like the Slateline® or Grand Sequoia® for enhanced curb appeal.
We prefer you to be available, but you don’t have to be at the house all day. We do roofs when people are on vacation, but we prefer you to be reachable in case there are any questions. Our production manager will be on-site supervising the entire process.
Yes! We offer financing options to help make your new roof more affordable. You can view our full financing options and apply online here.
Absolutely. Our team can assist you with HOA paperwork and approvals to ensure your roof project meets community guidelines and gets approved quickly.
This depends on the age and availability of your current shingles. We can typically match the same brand and color, but shingles naturally change color over the first few years, so an exact match is rare. That said, we can blend repairs and new shingles into your existing roof very effectively, making the repair or replacement look seamless.
Most asphalt roof replacements range from $475–$800 per square (100 square feet) depending on the materials chosen, roof complexity, and location of the job. Our free inspection and estimate will give you an exact price tailored to your home.